Freshly promoted, FBI agent Dave Maxwell continues his investigation into the highwayman murders while struggling with the limitations of no longer being a field agent. In his quest to track down the highwayman he travels to Romania to meet with an official with interpol who has evidence that reveals the identity of the Highwayman. 

But things are about to take an unusual turn.

On a cool November night outside Pittsburgh, in a developing suburb, four families are ruthlessly murdered in their homes. Detectives Bob Halsey and Ogden Chartrand are joined by FBI Special Agent, Michelle Leigh as they follow the trail of clues that will intersect with the nationwide hunt for the Highwayman.